Tag Archives: Mysteries
The mysterious non-mystery of boosting
Comments Off on The mysterious non-mystery of boostingMarch 9, 2016 · 8:00 am
Will I attend a MOOC?
The author of one of the best books on data visualization is giving a massively open online course (MOOC) this fall. I’m going to check it out. You may be interested, too.
What are HIV+ patients dying of?
A question that has been coming up in a lot of different forms lately is the title of this post: What are HIV+ patients dying of? In high-income settings, for people who are getting treatment, the answer seems to be known, by those in the know, and perhaps the definitive work is Causes of Death in HIV-1–Infected Patients Treated with Antiretroviral Therapy, 1996–2006: Collaborative Analysis of 13 HIV Cohort Studies.
Left unanswered is what is going on with people who are not getting treatment, who are not diagnosed, and who are not living in Europe or North America.
Comments Off on What are HIV+ patients dying of?
Filed under global health
What is “hello, world” for statistical graphics?
Tell me on cross-validated.
US Health Care Costs, cont.
I wrote two months ago about the mysterious differences in health care costs that I found so intriguing in a talk by Jonathan Skinner. (That was two months ago? Really?) Since then, the surgeon/author Atul Gawande has brought the mystery to the national stage. In a long story for the New Yorker, he gave the non-technical version of Skinner’s talk, and today he addressed some of the feedback that this article has received over the last month.
His short answer to the mystery is this:
Analysis of Medicare data by the Dartmouth Atlas project shows the difference is due to marked differences in the amount of care ordered for patients—patients in McAllen receive vastly more diagnostic tests, hospital admissions, operations, specialist visits, and home nursing care than in El Paso.
But that is not the end of the story. It only takes a sentence to explain the “proximal” cause of these cost differences, but it takes the whole article for Gawande to do justice to his theory on the underlying cause, and his is certainly not the only theory.
Since his theory of the root cause of this inequality is centered on physicians putting profit over patients, it has made some doctors uneasy. Greg Roth, a physician that I work with hadn’t had time to read the article when we last chatted, but he did attend Skinner’s talk with me two months ago. Greg told me about a detail that has emerged as doctors put Gawande’s article under their microscopes: we might be making a mountain out of molehill-sized mystery.
Look at this plot, which shows the complementary cumulative distribution function for the primary quantity in Gawande’s article, Total Medicare reimbursements per enrollee for 2006.
Investigative reporter have to get the story, and raking the muck way out in the tail of this distribution turned out to be a good bet this time. But McAllen is 6 standard deviations above the mean (not to imply that this distribution is normal… should it be?) How much impact would it have, for the whole population, if the outliers were greatly improved?
If through anti-fraud policing, better culture, and general hard work, the top 10% of hospitals reduced their cost per patient to the national average, that would reduce the average cost by 3.6%. Outliers show what is possible, but making a big change involves more than outliers.
Filed under global health, Mysteries
Mysterious Question: Differences in Health Care Costs
Health Economist Jonathan Skinner gave a talk at IHME about a week and a half ago. He told us about his work on the Dartmouth Atlas of Healthcare, and showed us some of the numbers he’s crunched on the variation of Medicare costs by region. He has found this mysterious, 2.5x variation between the cost of care between expensive regions (like Miami) and inexpensive regions (like Seattle). It seems like a great mystery, and I’ve been puzzling over it for a week now. Any theories? I’m partial to network effects.
Here’s his paper on the subject.
Filed under global health, Mysteries